In the brain of the monster, not the belly

Two helpful quotes about the identity of a privilege person in relation to oppressed people.
Andy Cornell in his letter to Punk Rock for the compilation Letters from Young Activists (http://www.lettersfromyoungactivists.org/):
"[Punk rock activism] blurred the line for us between oppression and exploitation on one hand, and alienation on the other...In the United States, punk is overwhelmingly a white and middle-class subculture. You channel and encourage the rage, anger, and disillusionment of largely privileged youth- and you are right to do so. But along the way, the racist police brutality, the poverty of minimum wage, the violence of rape and war that others feel becomes almost one and the same with the emptiness of consumer-culture, the stultifying pressure of middle-class expectations, and the boredom of cul-de-sac suburbia that we, much more immediately, feel in our lives. Oppression and alienation are connected, of course, but they are certainly not interchangeable. "
Multiple Authors in "Rethinking Solidarity" an article for Left Turn Magazine (http://www.leftturn.org/):
"It was a helpful reminder that Zapatistas do not consider their allies in the United States to be living so much in the 'belly of the beast' as in the 'brain of the monster'. In other words, the US is the place where neoliberal policies aimed at subverting global democracy are hatched and executed in communities around the world-including right here in the United States."
Labels: activism, capitalism, links

1 Comments:
Yep, I think that comment about the difference between alienation and oppression is key, very powerful to put it like that. And they're connected in that they're both the effects of white supremacy, heterosexism, the gender binary system, patriachy, capitalism and classism, etc. And, well, for me, to make fighting for liberation personal, it is important to recognize that part of why I want racial justice is because I don't want to feel disconnected from the realities of peoples of color. I don't want to feel debilitated by white guilt. I want to be able to have meaningful relationships with all people, including people of color. I want to be able to express anger and my desires for justice and have that be accepted and nurtured in my communities and culture(s). So racial justice is something that will benefit me, as a white person.
But at the same time, my 'white alienation' - if that can really be a term - is definitely not the same as living in fear of deportation, or not being able to live in the same country as my queer partner because we're not able to get married, or not being able to eat, or being incarcerated, or being poisoned by nuclear waste and pollution.
So I guess what I'm saying is, it's important to have a personal connection for fighting for liberation in areas where we are privileged. But also recognizing that, yeah, as Andy Cornell put it, alientation and oppression are different, but related.
Post a Comment
<< Home